You can view a list of the awards that Dylan has been nominated for as well as the ones he has won below. This list includes separate icons to showcase nominations/wins.
- = win
- = nomination
2015
- Teen Choice Award as Choice TV: Scene Stealer for Teen Wolf
- Teen Choice Award as Choice Movie Chemistry for The Maze Runner
- Teen Choice Award as Choice Movie Actor: Action/Adventure for The Maze Runner
- Melty Future Award as Prix International Masculin
- MTV Movie Award as Best Scared-As-S**t Performance for The Maze Runner
- MTV Movie Award as Best Breakthrough Performance for The Maze Runner
- MTV Movie Award as Best Fight for The Maze Runner
- MTV Movie Award as Best Hero for The Maze Runner
2014
- Teen Choice Award as Choice TV Villain for Teen Wolf
- (honored) Experience Award from Giffoni Film Festival
- Young Hollywood Award as Breakthrough Actor
- NewNowNext Award as Best New Film Actor for The Maze Runner
2013
- Young Hollywood Award as Best Ensemble for Teen Wolf